Hello! I used to think the same way until I saw a demantoid in person. They are not like any other garnet you’ve ever seen. They have more “fire” than a diamond, meaning they break light into a rainbow of colors more effectively. I recently added a piece from Tsarina Jewels https://tsarinajewels.com/ to my collection and the sparkle is just incredible. While an emerald has that deep color, a demantoid offers a brilliant, lively green that really catches the eye. In the realm of gemstones and high end jewelry, the Russian demantoid is considered the ultimate prize because of its history and its unique horsetail inclusions. It is definitely worth the attention if you want a stone that is rare, historic, and incredibly bright. I think they are a great alternative to emeralds for someone who wants more “life” and sparkle in their ring.